Reservation
(352) 682-9760
Visit Us
3270 SW 35th Blvd, Gainesville, FL 32608
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bagel Sandwiches
Vanilla Latte
Iced Coffee
Frozen Chai Latte
About
Bay Islands Coffee Company
Welcome to Bay Islands Coffee Company, a gem nestled in the heart of Gainesville, Florida. Located at 3270 SW 35th Blvd, this delightful coffee shop is more than just a place to grab your morning brew; it’s a beloved local hideaway that serves as a hub for the community, dedicated to delivering exquisite coffee experiences from dawn to dusk.
Bay Islands Coffee Company is renowned for its breakfast and brunch offerings. The menu showcases a variety of delectable items, including their mouthwatering bagel sandwiches, rich vanilla lattes, and the refreshing frozen chai latte. From the moment you step in or roll through the drive-thru, the enticing aromas of freshly brewed coffee transport you to a world of comfort and flavor.
The shop's iced coffee options, including the trendy iced mocha latte and the indulgent caramel iced coffee, are perfect for those warm Florida days. Patrons rave about the smooth house blend coffee that's crafted to perfection, whether you prefer it hot or iced. Sean Fredricks, a loyal customer, encapsulated this sentiment when he said, "Awesome small concept coffee shop... One of my brothers’ favorites in the area." It’s evident that the commitment to quality has earned Bay Islands a loyal following over the years.
The atmosphere at Bay Islands Coffee Company is as inviting as their beverages. With a mix of indoor and outdoor seating, it’s an ideal spot to catch up with friends or enjoy a quiet moment with a book. Reviews highlight the friendly staff, always eager with smiles and quick service, even during peak hours. Sarah Cousins shared her delight, commenting, “My Barista ROCKED!! I’ve ENJOYED coming here for over 10 years…” A testament to the warm community vibe that keeps customers returning.
If you're seeking a quick bite, their breakfast sandwich on an everything bagel is a must-try, perfectly pairing with a cup of their wonderful cappuccino. And for those who crave something chill, the frozen lemonade and smoothies are refreshing options that complement your coffee outing beautifully. As Ken noted, “One of the top best tasting coffees I've had.” That’s high praise from any coffee aficionado!
In conclusion, Bay Islands Coffee Company isn’t just a café; it’s a cherished community hub where delicious food meets warm hospitality. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and experience the magic for yourself. Your tastebuds will thank you!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Although I went at a busy time, My Barista ROCKED!! Ive ENJOYED coming here for over 10 years, and I will continue to come!! Continue the AMAZING work!! ”
“ Awesome small concept coffee shop. Offering both hot and iced options with a very very smooth house blend coffee. One of my brothers favorites in the area. They always have a line and for good reason. The staff is amazing and get orders moved quickly in my experience. The young ladies that serve the morning shift always have a smile and are very polite. I always get a cup when in town ”
“ It has a drive through! It also has outdoor seating. Smoothies and coffees available. Excellent flavor and syrup options. Plenty of smoothie choices and snacks as well. ”
“ Great, hot sandwich and cappuccino. The young lady was so sweet. She was by herself with a car line of about 4. We were walk ups and took our order quickly. ”
“ Super good coffee! Got the iced latte with the cinnamon bun syrup and oatmilk. Even with oatmilk it was really good! Also ordered the breakfast sandwich in an everything bagel , a frozen coconut coffee also really good!, and a fruit smoothie. One of the top best tasting coffees Ive had, probably better beans or roasting. The other reviews did not let down. The guy was rude But not so much, not in a way that we felt attacked. Seems like all they hire are rude people ”
“ Love this place! The chai latte and cheddar jalapeno bagel are worth the wait ”
“ Wait times can be a little long but honestly, I will always wait, my bagel is always perfect hot all the way through unlike other places where the egg will sometimes be cold in the center. my coffee is always exactly what I ordered Im obsessed with coffee ice cubes! ”
“ This tiny little hut is adorable and it packs a big punch! Is it a little slow with a long line? Yep! Is it totally worth it? Also YES! This is not some massive chain, it is the size of my suv with one person working inside, give them a little grace yall. Now, the coffee is fantastic! I got an iced caramel latte with 12 the caramel to cut down on sugar and it was soooo good! The sweet woman working also got me a little cup with whipped cream for my pup as he associates me getting coffee with him getting a pup cup. I will definitely be back to try the smoothies and other coffee options. ”